How many angels can dance on a pin


What was the origin of the old debate about how many angels can dance on the head of a pin? | Notes and Queries


Categories
Nooks and crannies
Yesteryear
Semantic enigmas
The body beautiful
Red tape, white lies
Speculative science
This sceptred isle
Root of all evil
Ethical conundrums
This sporting life
Stage and screen
Birds and the bees
ETHICAL CONUNDRUMS

What was the origin of the old debate about how many angels can dance on the head of a pin?

  • THIS POETICAL and interesting question was raised by Thomas Aquinas (1225-1274). He is known as the Father of Moral Philosophy and also as the Angelic Doctor because of his preoccupation with the qualities, nature and behaviour of these celestial beings. He was canonised in 1323.

    Muriel Cottrell, Wirral, Merseyside.

  • IT IS OFTEN used disparagingly about theological speculation. In a long past BBC Brains Trust session, the late Prof C. E. M. Joad used the expression in that way. The following week he was firmly denounced for loose thinking by a listener who claimed, with apparent authority, that there was no evidence that this subject was ever debated. On the other hand, he said, monks in medieval times would, purely as a recreation, hold rigidly structured debates on all kinds of unlikely subjects. So the "angels" debate could have originated from such a source. Joad had, it seemed, no answer to that. Nor have I - it just stays in the memory from the old Brains Trust days.

    Stephen Fearnley, Halifax, W Yorks.

  • I WAS interested to read the comments on this dispute. However, I think the idea behind it was whether angels had dimensions and occupied space. If they did not, then clearly an infinity of angels could dance on the sharpest, most needle-fine point. Milton gets round the difficulty most beautifully in Book One of Paradise Lost when he makes the Fallen Angels appear first "In bigness to surpass Earth's Giant Sons' and then to "throng numberless' in Pandemonium like tiny elves - "incorporeal Spirits".

    Laura Garratt, Uxbridge, Middx.

  • Laura Garrett is halfway there. The 'size of angels' is important as an answer to this question : is God bound by the physical laws of His universe ( ie. a finite number of angels ) or is He able to transcend his own laws and thereby fit an infinite number of angels on a pin ? Obviously this applies generally and not just to angels and pins, and so is quite an important question. Probably.

    John Mys, Birmingham, UK

Add your answer

angels dancing on the head of a pin

See also: angels-dancing-on-the-head-of-a-pin

Contents

  • 1 English
    • 1. 1 Etymology
    • 1.2 Noun
      • 1.2.1 Translations
      • 1.2.2 See also

English[edit]

English Wikipedia has an article on:

How many angels can dance on the head of a pin?

Wikipedia

Etymology[edit]

An allusion to the theological question “How many angels can dance on the head of a pin?” — a question cited to debunk mediaeval angelology in particular and scholasticism in general. The point is that explorative discussions that the discussants consider important can be academic in both senses of that word—not only arcane but also irrelevant.

Noun[edit]

angels dancing on the head of a pin pl (plural only)

  1. (figuratively) The subject of arcane intellectual speculation; used as an example subject of enquiry the pursuit of which is of no value.
    • 1965, United States Congress House Government Operations, Procurement of a Cryogenic Cooling System for Fighter Aircraft: Hearing, 89-1, June 8–9, 1965, page 47:

      We are not talking about angels dancing on the head of a pin here.

    • 1995, Julian Lincoln Simon, The State of Humanity, page 358:

      …logically indistinguishable from the argument that because we do not know at what rate the angels dancing on the head of a pin are dying off…

    • 2001, William C. Gaventa & David L. Coulter, The Theological Voice of Wolf Wolfensberger, page 6:

      The issues Dr. Wolfensberger wrestles with and writes about are not intellectual discussions of angels dancing on the head of a pin.

Translations[edit]

arcane intellectual speculation

  • Finnish: neulan kärjellä tanssivat enkelit
  • French: sexe des anges m, le sexe des anges m, querelle byzantine (fr) f
  • Italian: il sesso degli angeli m
  • Portuguese: sexo dos anjos m, o sexo dos anjos m
  • Spanish: el sexo de los ángeles m
See also[edit]
  • angels-dancing-on-the-head-of-a-pin
  • count angels on pinheads

How many angels are on the end of the needle?

?
How many angels are on the end of the needle? [Aug. 16th, 2007| 05:33pm ]

Quote exactly!


There is a widespread misconception that in medieval scholasticism the question was debated as to how many angels fit (or: dance) on the end of a needle or pin. Attributed to Thomas Aquinas. nine0018 In rebuttal - article from the English Wikipedia: The "how many angels?" question - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia - and further links, for example: Straight Dope Classic: Did medieval scholars argue over how many angels could dance on the head of a pin?

Attachment: Myths about the Middle Ages - about the right of the first night, flat earth and so on.

Comments:
From: nyq
2007-08-16 10:38 pm (UTC)

the claim that the "Renaissance" is almost entirely a beat-up, put about by a gang of anti-Catholic art historians , has much to be said for it

(bold is mine)

This is a stylistic device (and rhetoric in general) characteristic of creationists: when they are pressed into a corner by indisputable facts proving the existence and efficiency of evolution, they call their opponents a "gang of anti-Christians", "goal-fighters" and other impressive terms. nine0013

This is to say that, of course, the Greeks knew the roundness of the forms of the Earth, no one will argue with this, but this does not mean that the Middle Ages were all white and fluffy from head to toe.

FROM: Korob_Kov
2007-08-16 11:32 PM (UTC)

Middle Ages, of course, was not white and fluffy, but this is not canceled that it is not canceled that it is not canceled that it is not canceled that "Renaissance" is an ideologically loaded term, and the described ideological construction (the revival of true culture after centuries of darkness and barbarism) is terribly far from reality, and, therefore, the judgment of it as an ideological distortion is correct. nine0013

FROM: m_ike
2008-03-21 02:50 PM (UTC)
9005 +1

of this record should not be here at all. To cite as an argument a link to a self-made "encyclopedia" and the site of some Catholic apologist - does not correspond to the level of the community. And this is actually a curtain:

I have not been able to turn up the text D'Israeli refers to (my 17th-century files are just a mess)...
At this point, an honest person should be modestly silent.

%d0%b2%d0%ba%d0%b8 in English - Russian-English Dictionary

Sample translated sentence: He was hit by a car on December 20 last year. ↔ Died in a traffic accident on December 20.

  • Glosbe Translate

  • Google Translate

  • nine0129

    + Add translation Add

    Currently we have no translations for d0%b2%d0%ba%d0%b8 in the dictionary, maybe you can add one? Make sure to check automatic translation, translation memory or indirect translations.

    add example Add

    Declension Stem

    4.3.2 [ 20 ] <4.1, 4.2> Show how this block can be implemented.

    4.3.2 [ 20 ] <4.1, 4.2> Show how this block can be implemented.

    Literature

    Where a State not party to the Statute has agreed to provide assistance to the Court in accordance with paragraph 5 of article 87 and has not chosen the language in which such requests are to be submitted, requests for cooperation shall be submitted either in one of the working languages ​​of the Court or accompanied by translation into one of these languages.

    When a State not party to the Statute has agreed to provide assistance to the Court under article 87 , paragraph 5, and has not made a choice of language for such requests, the requests for cooperation shall either be in or be accompanied by a translation into one of the working languages ​​of the Court.

    The caesarean section rate in Italy has risen markedly over the last 20 years from 11. 2% (1980) to 33.2% (2000) and is 10% to 15% higher than WHO recommendations and other European countries (e.g. 21.5 percent in the UK and Wales, 17.8 percent in Spain, 15.9percent in France).

    Caesarean section rate in Italy has remarkably increased in the last 20 years, from 11.2% (1980) to 33.2% (2000), a value exceeding WHO suggestions by 10 to 15% and other European Countries' values ​​(i.e. 21.5 % in Great Britain and Wales, 17.8% in Spain, 15.9% in France).

    In addition, article 20 of the Constitution states that primary education in public schools is compulsory and free.

    Article 20 also provides that basic education is compulsory and is free of charge in Government schools.

    At 20 40 hours two enemy Israeli warplanes violated Lebanese airspace over Marjayoun.

    At 2040 hours, two enemy Israeli warplanes violated Lebanese airspace over Marjaayoun, flying north.

    Song Pokemon Mezase PokeMon Master Aim To Be A PokeMon Master is brought to you by Lyrics-Keeper. Flash feature can be used as karaoke for Mezase PokeMon Master Aim To 9 song0042 Be A PokeMon Master, if you can download the backing track.

    The Pokemon Mezase PokeMon Master Aim To Be A PokeMon Master lyrics are brought to you by Lyrics-Keeper.

    Addendum

    He was hit by a car on December 20, last year.

    Died in a traffic accident on December 20 .

    OpenSubtitles2018.v3

    If the contents are heat sensitive, or if the aerosol dispensers are made of plastic that softens at this test temperature, the water temperature should be maintained within 20 -30°C; however, in addition to this, one in 2,000 aerosol dispensers must be tested at a higher temperature.

    If the contents are sensitive to heat or if the aerosol dispensers are made of plastics material which softens at this test temperature, the temperature of the bath shall be set at between 20 °C and 30 °C but, in addition, one aerosol dispenser in 2000 shall be tested at the higher temperature.

    Design 273 Again: to be , not to be eaten.

    Construction 273 To to , not to to eaten.

    Literature

    How appropriate, after all, graduates were appointed to serve in 20 countries of the world!

    (Matthew 28:19, 20) How appropriate that was, since the graduates are being sent to serve in 20 different countries!

    jw2019

    The Governing Council of the United Nations Environment Program (UNEP), in its decision 25/10 of 20 February 2009 noted the outcome of the first ad hoc multi-stakeholder intergovernmental meeting on the intergovernmental science-policy platform on biodiversity and ecosystem services, held 10-12 November 2008 in Putrajaya, Malaysia, and recognized and emphasized the need to strengthen and strengthening the science-policy interface on biodiversity and ecosystem services for human well-being and sustainable development at all levels. nine0013

    The Governing Council of the United Nations Environment Program (UNEP), by its decision 25/10 of 20 February 2009, noted the outcomes of the first ad hoc intergovernmental and multi-stakeholder meeting on an intergovernmental science-policy platform on biodiversity and ecosystem services, held in Putrajaya, Malaysia, from 10 to 12 November 2008, and recognized and emphasized the need to strengthen and improve the science-policy interface for biodiversity and ecosystem services for human well-being and sustainable development at all levels. nine0013

    Another 10 minutes for 20 lifts.

    10 more minutes you got two 20s .

    OpenSubtitles2018.v3

    You'll be left with 20 percent as an agent, and I'll take 80 percent.

    You keep 20 percent of the royalties, like an agent.

    OpenSubtitles2018.v3

    I knew how much God values ​​man and his body, but even that didn't stop me. Jennifer, 20 years

    I knew of God’s high regard for the human body, but even this did not deter me.” —Jennifer 20 .

    jw2019

    Implementation of an expanded wireless network to provide better coverage of all main UNMIL premises (meeting rooms) and locations containing 20 or more UNMIL staff users, including living quarters.

    Implementation of extended wireless system to cover all main UNMIL facilities (conference rooms) and areas where 20 or more UNMIL users are present, including residences.

    If you are ready to take a little advice from a friend, rest, sleep” 20 .

    If you will now accept some advice from a friend—get some rest, get some sleep.

    Literature

    In 1998, by the Decree of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine N 513 of on April 20, , she was named after the outstanding statesman and scientist Professor Platon Lukich Shupik (1907-1986), who twice served as Minister of Health of Ukraine (1952-1954 , 1956-1969), made a significant contribution to the development of the material, educational and scientific base of the Academy, for 14 years (1965-1979) headed the Department of Social Medicine and Health Organization (now the Department of Health Management).

    The Institute got a new qualification in 1996, in the year of the 5th anniversary of Ukrainian independence. On the 13th of May 1996 the Resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers "On the Formation of Kyiv Medical Academy of Post-graduate Education" was issued, according to it the Academy was considered to be an educational institution of a new type and higher (IV ) level of accreditation. nine0013 Addendum

    Please note that the annex to the report of the Co-Chairs has already been circulated to Member States as a document of the General Assembly and the Economic and Social Council (A/63/85-E/2008/ 83 ).

    We would like to point out that an annex to the report of the co-Chairs has already been distributed to Member States as a document of the General Assembly and the Economic and Social Council (A/63/85-E/2008/ 83 ).

    The Hungarian Parliament adopted the International Convention for the Suppression of Terrorist Bombings (10 September 2002) and the International Convention for the Suppression of the Financing of Terrorism ( 20 December 2002).

    The Hungarian Parliament promulgated the International Convention for the Suppression of Terrorist Bombings (on 10 September 2002) and the International Convention for the Suppression of the Financing of Terrorism (on 20 December 2002).

    K 20 9On September 0043, a large grouping of Soviet troops, including the 42nd division, was locked in the Kiev "boiler".

    By 20 September a large group of Soviet troops, including the 42nd Division, was locked in Kiev cauldron.

    WikiMatrix

    This prescription is given as remark 35 in column 20 of table C of chapter 3.2.

    This requirement is indicated by remark 35 in column ( 20 ) of Table C of Chapter 3.2;

    According to the 2015 national survey of coca cultivation in the Plurinational State of Bolivia, the area under coca bush cultivation in 2015 remained virtually unchanged at 20 200 ha, the lowest since 2001.

    According to the 2015 national coca monitoring survey in the Plurinational State of Bolivia, the level of cultivation of coca bush remained stable, at 20,200 ha in 2015, the lowest level recorded since 2001.

    that He is a jealous God (Ex 20 :5, Deut 5:9).

    God demands worship and announces himself to be a jealous God (Ex 20 :5; Deut 5:9).

    Literature

    For example, in such cities as Dushanbe and Khujand, during the winter period 20 -30% of the demand for heating in residential and administrative buildings is not satisfied due to insufficient heat and electricity supply.

    In the cities of Dushanbe and Khujand, for example, it is estimated that as much as 20 -30 percent of residential and public heating demands are not met during winter months due to insufficient heat and electricity supplies. nine0013 worldbank.org

    With regard to new methods of financing, the European Union supports the Declaration of Heads of State and Government, heads of international organizations and leaders of civil society adopted 20 September 2004 at a meeting held under the auspices of the United Nations.


    Learn more

.